Cabbage Soup Diets - Do They Work?

Just about everyone who has considered losing weight has heard about cabbage soup diets at some time or other. Many people, when they first hear about this diet believe that it is new or revolutionary. The diet claims to help you miraculously lose 10-15 pounds in 7 days. But is this true? Let's take a look.

There are a lot of misconceptions about cabbage soup diets, including the origins. Some sources claim that it was created by a famous doctor; some sources attribute it to a respectable hospital but there is no proof either way. The true origins are unknown.

The diet seems to have first surfaced in the 1980’s and spread by word of mouth an through the media. Once the Internet arrived, it quickly spread that way. This is one of those diets that seems like it will never die or go away.

What is the cabbage soup diet?

It's a 7 day eating plan that revolves around a soup which is comprised mainly of cabbage. The eating plan is below:

Day 1 - Cabbage soup and any type of fruit that you would like to eat, except for bananas.

Day 2 - Cabbage soup and any vegetables that you care to eat. You may also have a baked potato that has a small amount of butter on it.

Day 3 - Cabbage soup plus any fruits or vegetables that you care to eat, with the exception of potatoes or bananas.

Day 4 - Cabbage soup and bananas. You may eat up to 8 bananas. You may also drink as much skim milk as you want too.

Day 5 - Cabbage soup and beef. You may have up to 20 ounces of beef this day along with the cabbage soup. You may also consume up to 6 tomatoes.

Day 6 - Cabbage soup and unlimited beef. This day you can have as much beef as you care to eat. You can also have as many vegetables as you want, except for potatoes.

Day 7 - Cabbage soup and brown rice. You may also have any vegetables that you want this day, except potatoes. You may drink unsweetened fruit juice this day too.

It should be noted that you may eat as much of the cabbage soup that you want on any of the days. You must eat the cabbage soup at least 3 times per day. There are also slight variations of this diet. The main ingredients usually consist of the following: cabbage, onion, carrots, tomatoes, peppers, and seasonings. The ingredients for the cabbage soup also tend to vary.

Does this diet work?

Yes and no. The diet can work, if you actually stick to it for the 7 days. You are severely limiting your calorie intake. Given that you have to eat the same thing daily, will probably tend to make you want to eat less of the soup, which will even further restrict your daily calorie intake.

If you’re expecting the weight loss to be long term, don’t. Most of the weight you lose from this diet will be water weight, not fat. Once you resume your normal eating habits, the weight you lost will return. In fact, it is probable that you will not only gain the weight you lost while being on this diet, but you may even gain more weight. You could wind up heavier than before you started this diet after you resume your normal eating habits.

Is this diet safe?

Ask your doctor for his recommendation. Chances are, he will question the nutrional soundness of it and be totally put off by the lack of daily calories. It is possible to become malnourished while on this diet. Being on this diet would mean you're close to consuming less than 1200 calories. Even though it is only a week, it is a questionable practice regarding your health.

Cabbage soup diets live on because there will always be an allure and an attraction to a diet that will help you to lose weight rapidly. But there are many other safe, nutritionally sound, diets out there that will help you to lose weight if you put the effort into them.